Oooh that's a tough choice and here's why for me.


Did he did the murder himself - Innocent. (timings, alibi and blood)



Could he have planned it - ?

Did he have nothing to do with it - Probable.


So, given that his guilt has to be beyond reasonable doubt for him to be found guilty. I would have to say innocent.


Re: Menlove Gdns East. I know the lure of commission would be great but it was quite a way out of his district for calling-collecting money. Did he have any other customers this far out that would require all that travelling every time he collected?