View Full Version : Calls to tackle violence against hospital workers


Shapers
04-02-2007, 09:09 PM
NEARLY one in seven staff members were violently assaulted by patients at some of the region's hospitals last year, a survey has revealed.

The study found that 14% of workers at St Helens & Knowsley Hospitals trust were attacked by the people they were trying to help.

The violence was almost as bad at Southport & Ormskirk trust (13%), Aintree Hospitals (12%) and the Walton Centre for Neurology and Neurosurgery (11%).

But even those figures were dwarfed by the 26% of staff at the North West Ambulance Service who reported an assault by a patient in 2006.

Many ambulance and hospital workers also told researchers that they had suffered violence at the hands of the relatives of patients.


The independent Healthcare Commission, which carried out the survey, said it was worried by the findings and called for renewed action to tackle the violence.

Anna Walker, chief executive of the watchdog, said: "We are calling on trusts to redouble their efforts in this area.

"We must all adopt a zero tolerance policy to such behaviour. NHS staff deserve our respect and praise for what is often life-saving work, not violence and abuse."

And Karen Jennings, Unison's national health officer said: "It's time to say enough is enough. NHS workers are seeing their personal safety gradually deteriorate."

The survey revealed big discrepancies across the region in the proportion of hospital staff reporting violent attacks by patients.

The Countess of Chester Hospital (10%), Royal Liverpool & Broadgreen University Hospitals (9%) and Wirral Hospital (9%) had the next highest figures.

In contrast, 2% of workers at the Clatterbridge Centre for Oncology and Liverpool Women's Hospital were assaulted.

The survey of more than 126,000 staff across England found that, on average, 12% of hospital staff had been attacked by a patient and 3% by a patient's relative.

Just over half of those surveyed said they would not be happy with the standard of care provided in their trust if they were a patient.

But the NHS Security Management Service said the number of physical assaults dipped slightly in the year to October 2006, falling by 1,690 compared to 2004-05.

And the department for health pointed to a 1,600% increase in the number of prosecutions for abusing NHS staff over the last three years.

The survey mostly covered a period before the introduction of £1,000 fines to punish people who abuse or threaten health workers.

Hospital managers were also given greater powers to remove offenders from the premises, under the proposals designed to foster a "culture of respect".

Shapers
04-02-2007, 09:13 PM
Anyone who comes into hospital and threatens or abuses staff should cease being treated immediatley. Not talking about the elderley with alzheimers or mental problems, but some pr*ck whos coked off his head or been in a fight and is full of aggression should just be left to bleed.

Why should Doctors and Nurses have to remain professional to scum?

steveb
04-02-2007, 09:16 PM
This is nothing new, been happening for years, not just NHS staff but
Fire Service and police.
It is getting bad so much so that some hospitals now have a mini Police
station on site. If you wan't to see it 1st hand spend a few hours at RLH
AE on a saturday night.

Shapers
04-02-2007, 09:23 PM
I have been in the Royal waiting room and if it is at night, you can guarantee there will be drunks, either old men or women giving verbals, or a gang of scally lads demanding they get preferential treatment and intimidate the staff. Sickening.

steveb
04-02-2007, 09:35 PM
I have been in the Royal waiting room and if it is at night, you can guarantee there will be drunks, either old men or women giving verbals, or a gang of scally lads demanding they get preferential treatment and intimidate the staff. Sickening.

This is true. Don't know if the RLH has a confinment room were security
stick trouble makers. The room isn't locked so the person can leave, but with a security person outside few do until the bobbies arrive. Again new technology means that staff have radio personal attack buttons which indicate at security exactly were the person is. Medical staff can refuse
to treat trouble makers as long as the problem isn't life threatening, same
goes for Ambulance crews

Shapers
04-02-2007, 09:42 PM
I know the Royal has a bobbie stationed there at weekends, but i think the idea the supermarkets proposals the they will have a police rooms in there stores, like the police reception for people to report crimes, would it not be better if hospitals had them also. Be good if someone came in after being attacked could also report the crime whilst waiting for treatment.

Quite possible this has been proposed already, could somebody confirm this if it has.

steveb
04-02-2007, 09:50 PM
I know the Royal has a bobbie stationed there at weekends, but i think the idea the supermarkets proposals the they will have a police rooms in there stores, like the police reception for people to report crimes, would it not be better if hospitals had them also. Be good if someone came in after being attacked could also report the crime whilst waiting for treatment.

Quite possible this has been proposed already, could somebody confirm this if it has.

As I said, some hospitals do have a room setup as a police station, manned 24/7 by 2 bobbies, and as you say tis not just for trouble, but any problem
theft, or just info can be reported.

Shapers
04-02-2007, 09:51 PM
As I said, some hospitals do have a room setup as a police station, manned 24/7 by 2 bobbies, and as you say tis not just for trouble, but any problem
theft, or just info can be reported.

ah right, and does the Royal have this facility?

steveb
04-02-2007, 09:56 PM
ah right, and does the Royal have this facility?

Not sure, but seem to remember seeing it either on Teletext or in the Echo
Great deterent a bobby walking round with stab proof vest on, side handle
baton, qwik cuffs the lot..

lindylou
04-03-2007, 10:26 AM
They have security in schools now. My son's school has an on site police officer.

Who would have thought it would come to this ... needing police presence in the hospitals and schools.

Kev
04-03-2007, 10:29 AM
They have security in schools now. My son's school has an on site police officer.



How effective is the police officer's presence?

lindylou
04-03-2007, 10:46 AM
Not sure really, there is a new head there too who is very strict - but my son still tells me that fights are a regular thing. They still happen all the time and teachers have to wade in to break it up.
he says that the kids don't take much notice of the policeman !

I suppose it's useful to have police on site though in case anything worse should occur.

Kev
04-03-2007, 10:59 AM
he says that the kids don't take much notice of the policeman !



That's what I thought.

steveb
04-03-2007, 11:14 AM
Not sure really, there is a new head there too who is very strict - but my son still tells me that fights are a regular thing. They still happen all the time and teachers have to wade in to break it up.
he says that the kids don't take much notice of the policeman !

I suppose it's useful to have police on site though in case anything worse should occur.

Bit late then though :-)

Klaatu
04-03-2007, 11:45 AM
What's the world coming to?:shock: